Education, Science, Technology, Innovation and Life
Open Access
Sign In

System Evaluation and Meta Analysis Re-evaluation of Oral Preparation of Traditional Chinese Medicine in the Treatment of Children's Hand, Foot and Mouth Disease

Download as PDF

DOI: 10.23977/phpm.2022.020210 | Downloads: 3 | Views: 119

Author(s)

Kexin Wang 1, Xuan Jin 2, Lin Tao 1, Qilao Song 2

Affiliation(s)

1 Shaanxi University of traditional Chinese medicine, Xianyang 712000, China
2 Affiliated Hospital of Shaanxi University of traditional Chinese Medicine, Xianyang 712000, China

Corresponding Author

Qilao Song

ABSTRACT

Objective Reevaluate the quality of literature report, methodology and evidence of systematic evaluation / meta-analysis of oral preparation of traditional Chinese medicine in the treatment of children's hand, foot and mouth disease (HFMD). Methods Search the systematic evaluation / meta-analysis literatures as of December 2021 from China Academic Journal Database (Wan Fang Data), China knowledge resource database (CNKI), China biomedical literature service system (SinoMed), Chinese scientific and technological journal database (VIP). Two researchers independently conduct literature screening and data extraction, and apply PRISMA statement, AMSTAR 2 tool and GRADE system to evaluate the literature quality. Results A total of 16 literatures were included and a number of 73 outcome indicators were included; the evaluation results of AMSTAR 2 showed that 5 were of low quality and 11 were of very low quality; GRADE showed that the evidence quality grade of one outcome index was medium, 17 were low and 55 were very low. Conclusion The methodological quality of systematic evaluation / meta-analysis of oral preparation of traditional Chinese medicine in the treatment of HFMD is low and very low, and the evidence quality level of outcome indicators is mostly very low. It is urgent to carry out systematic evaluation with high quality and high evidence intensity, so as to provide high-level evidence to guide clinical practice.

KEYWORDS

Oral Preparation of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Hand foot mouth disease in children, Systematic evaluation, PRISMA, AMSTAR2, GRADE

CITE THIS PAPER

Kexin Wang, Xuan Jin, Lin Tao, Qilao Song, System Evaluation and Meta Analysis Re-evaluation of Oral Preparation of Traditional Chinese Medicine in the Treatment of Children's Hand, Foot and Mouth Disease. MEDS Public Health and Preventive Medicine (2022) Vol. 2: 59-70. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.23977/phpm.2022.020210.

REFERENCES

[1] Deng Huiling, Gao J, Huang Xueyong, et al. Guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of hand, foot and mouth disease (2018 edition)[J]. Chinese Journal of Infectious Diseases, 2018,36(05):257-263.
[2] Li Jialing, Wei Yujia, Dong Boqing, et al. A study on the trend of morbidity and mortality of hand, foot and mouth disease in China from 2008-2017[J]. Disease Surveillance, 2021:1-14.
[3] Wu K X, Ng M M, Chu J J. Developments towards antiviral therapies against enterovirus 71[J]. Drug Discov Today, 2010,15(23-24):1041-1051.
[4] Xue Bailin, Yao Zhihong, Yu Rongmin. Anti-EV71 virus activity of Chinese herbal medicines and its application in the treatment of hand, foot and mouth disease[J]. Chinese Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2011,36(23):3366-3370.
[5] Guidelines for the treatment of hand, foot and mouth disease (2010 edition) [J]. International Journal of Respiratory Medicine, 2010(24):1473-1475.
[6] David Moher, Alessandro Liberati, Jennifer Tetzlaff, et al. Priority reporting entries for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement [J]. Journal of Integrated Chinese and Western Medicine, 2009,7(09):889-896.
[7] Zhang Fangyuan, Shen Aomei, Zeng Xiantao, et al. Interpretation of the systematic evaluation methodological quality assessment tool AMSTAR 2[J]. Chinese Journal of Evidence-Based Cardiovascular Medicine, 2018,10(01):14-18.
[8] Chen YL, Yao L, Susan Norris, et al. The need for and considerations of GRADE in systematic evaluation[J]. Chinese Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine, 2013,13(12):1401-1404.
[9] Chen Fuchao, Fang Baoxia, Chen Xi, et al. Meta-analysis of Pudilan anti-inflammatory oral solution and ribavirin in the treatment of hand, foot and mouth disease in children[J]. Journal of Modern Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine, 2011,20(32):4053-4055.
[10] Huang J, Zhang QL, Pi FJ, et al. Systematic evaluation of Pudilan anti-inflammatory oral solution in the treatment of pediatric hand, foot, and mouth disease[J]. China Hospital Drug Evaluation and Analysis, 2020,20(07):845-849.
[11] Zhou YK, Zhang XUEYAN. Meta-analysis of busulfan anti-inflammatory oral solution combined with ribavirin in the treatment of pediatric hand, foot and mouth disease[J]. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Medicine, 2014,13(13):1058-1062.
[12] Guo Hongju, Shi Ning, Wang Huan, et al. A meta-analysis of pediatric black bean and chiao clearing fever granules combined with Budilan anti-inflammatory oral solution in the treatment of hand, foot, and mouth disease[J]. Pharmacy Service and Research, 2018,18(01):48-51.
[13] Wang Shiheng, Qin Peijie, Liu Jianfeng, et al. Systematic evaluation of Pudilan oral solution combined with western medicine in the treatment of hand, foot and mouth disease[J]. World TCM, 2021,16(08):1231-1240.
[14] Yang Z, Lv J, Sun M H, et al. Systematic evaluation of the efficacy and safety of Blue Scutellaria Oral Liquid in the treatment of pediatric hand, foot and mouth disease[J]. Chinese Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2020,45(15):3547-3555.
[15] Chen Huihui, Yao Yinhui. Meta-analysis of the effect of Blue Scutellaria oral solution in the treatment of hand, foot and mouth disease[J]. China Medical Engineering, 2020,28(02):4-10.
[16] Shi N, Guo HJ, Wang HH, et al. Meta-analysis on the treatment of pediatric hand, foot and mouth disease with Jinlian Qinghe effervescent tablets[J]. Journal of Liberation Army Pharmacy, 2017,33(01):102-105.
[17] Wu JT, Chang Cheng, Hu SY, et al. Meta-analysis on the evaluation of efficacy of Jinlian Qinghe effervescent tablets in the treatment of hand, foot and mouth disease (common type) in children[J]. Henan Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2017,37(09):1588-1591.
[18] Nie Wenyi, Lv Jian, Xie Yanming, et al. Systematic evaluation and Meta-analysis of pediatric Chai Gui antipyretic granules in the treatment of hand, foot and mouth disease[J]. Chinese Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2020,45(15):3539-3546.
[19] Liu Liao, Jia Ping, Chen Fang, et al. Systematic evaluation of the efficacy of Kangfu Xin Liquid in the treatment of hand, foot and mouth disease[J]. Chinese Journal of Experimental Formulary, 2012,18(24):13-19.
[20] Dai Yanqing, Ding Jieying, Xu Biqi. Meta-analysis on the treatment of hand, foot and mouth disease in children with Spironolactone tablets[J]. Journal of Clinical Rational Drug Use, 2017,10(16):103-104.
[21] Li L, Ma Y, Fu Qiangqiang. Systematic evaluation of the effect of combining antiviral drugs with Lianhua Qingfei granules in the treatment of hand, foot and mouth disease in children[J]. China Maternal and Child Health, 2021,36(24):5847-5851.
[22] Zhang Guoliang, Wei Chaoyu. Meta-analysis of Chinese medicine in the treatment of hand, foot and mouth disease[J]. World Journal of Integrated Chinese and Western Medicine, 2014,9(02):122-125.
[23] Yu Y, Zhang G, Huang H, et al. Meta-analysis of the clinical efficacy of Plus and Minus Yin Qiao San in the treatment of hand, foot and mouth disease[J]. Chinese Traditional Chinese Medicine Emergency, 2016,25(04):590-593.
[24] Zhang Y, Zhu C-L, Huang M-Y. Systematic evaluation of the efficacy of combined Chinese and Western medicine in the treatment of hand, foot and mouth disease in children[J]. Journal of Tropical Medicine, 2014,14(09):1151-1155.
[25] Andrew F, Claudia W, Jianping L, et al. GP-TCM Unabridged guidelines for randomised controlled trials investigating Chinese herbal medicine (CHM) [J]. European Journal of Integrative Medicine, 2014,6(2).
[26] Cumpston M, Li T, Page M J, et al. Updated guidance for trusted systematic reviews: a new edition of the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions[J]. Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2019,10:D142.
[27] Page M J, Shamseer L, Tricco A C. Registration of systematic reviews in PROSPERO: 30,000 records and counting[J]. Syst Rev, 2018,7(1):32.

Downloads: 222
Visits: 15296

Sponsors, Associates, and Links


All published work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Copyright © 2016 - 2031 Clausius Scientific Press Inc. All Rights Reserved.